Congratulations to PA reader and huge pervert Desirae! I love the "Vaginger Snaps" but for me this one wins because of the incredible depiction of cookie penetration.
A disgusting re-imagining of a classic kids game. Love the sperm!
The camel's humps are the testicles! Truly inspired.
I'll be contacting the winners today. The top three listed here will all get a special Penny Arcade prize pack of stuff from our store.
Here is a gallery with a few more entries that I loved but didn't quite make the cut. This is very NSFW! You have been warned.
Thanks to everyone who entered. You are all perverts and I love you!